Our “Mackinaw Crossings” Original Murdick’s Fudge Store Serves As A Lower Peninsula Gateway To The Mackinac Bridge. While other fudge stores may claim to be the “original” Murdick’s Fudge, the only Original Murdick’s Fudge shop in Mackinaw City is inside the downtown Mackinaw Crossings entertainment complex. The mall is located at 190 S. Huron, Mackinaw City, MI 49701. Contact store manager Kelly in our Mackinaw Crossings fudge shop if you have any questions.